My Photo
Powered by TypePad

« In The Balance - Part II | Main | Catchphrase Monday »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834521cbc69e200e55021faa98833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference In The Balance - Part III: Finale:

Comments

Rohit

Very nicely done...ass-munch!

Brandon

Good story, great writing. . . . .and I'm pretty sure Jesus would be wearing a track suit. I mean, if he's gonna be jogging, he might as well fit the part.

UnderwearNinja

What else would he be wearing while jogging? Makes perfect sense to me.

emily

now i feel like the ass-munch.

glad the story ended this way!

cathy in canada

wicked story telling/writing ...i smell a book.

jw

This is a wonderful story that SHOULD have had a profound effect on you. But did it? I think not!

After going through something so traumatic you should have learned something, but you didn't.

The message you should have gotten from this experience comes from a very wise woman, “You shouldn’t swear.”

sue

You are a terrific storyteller... I'D buy a book you wrote! Please don't stop.

Almost Lucid (Brad)

I'm really glad your brother is ok. Your perspective on the story is what I like the most. Alone and lonely truly are different things.

Jillian

Wow, GREAT story. I thought it was going to be MUCH more serious. You really led us into that one!

Nice job, again.

I'll be back for more Witt. ;-)

frstlymil

Bravo. Well told. And had every possible ingredient. Fear, tears, humor, name calling by boys, happy ending, And I agree about the book.

panajane

That was a great story, ass-munch.

Michael

I realize that you had to tell it the way you experienced it, and perhaps the details of the ordeal were a little hazy after the fact, but it still seemed a tad anti-climactic. A great story, but feel free to fill in some of the details there. I want to know more!

tj

I'm inclined to agree with Michael somewhat. While I certainly like the piece, there is a sense of imbalance between the introductory parts I and II and the dramatic part III. It could just be that what's discussed in the first two parts (this idea of the tie-breaking birth and how that made you important to your brother, and vice versa) isn't brought back around in the third part.

I don't mean to be overly critical, I'm a big fan of your stuff and visit on a regular basis (and even die laughing at gems of comments left in others' sites), but something just felt a little off about this piece.

As for Michael's other comment about having to "tell it the way you experienced it," my question is (for everyone): Do you? Even in nonfiction there's room to breathe in recreating the details, and even the point of view from which it's told. Speculation for the sake of dramatization is acceptable, isn't it? I mean, we accept that the dialogue in this piece is probably not verbatim, but instead has an "emotional truth."

Sorry for such a long (and kind of workshoppy) comment. I really do love the site.

cw

Thanks for the feedback. I definitely hear what you're saying on it being anticlimactic. The whole story is probably something I could've spent a little more time trying to perfect. Maybe I'll go back and do that someday.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Links